1/4. The first 3 CCC's popped around the 2 hour mark. The fourth popped after 3.5 hours and dropped the sword. Perhaps longer spawn increases chance of drop. Also had TH1 on all 4 attempts.
I went 1/5 on Nadrs. Took me an entire weekend bc I would leave after killing him to do something else. I killed him on smn72/thf15 and always had a friend come out and give me TH2. 4/5 times I had TH2 and only once did it drop. Really boring to camp so I just left after each kill or logged for two hours. Always had to kill at least 3 place holders when the 2 hours were up. I noticed that CCC always spawns on or very near the bridge right next to the sea monk.I would summon carby and let him get hate then pull carby off of him and turn my back.. This way carby tanks it. I would do this until my thf friend would arrive. DO NOT disengage! CCC will become unclaimed even if he is still attacking carby. I know being unclaimed isn't a prob with this guy but you never know.... Some retard might run by and see a cool name to kill :P Drop rate is 10% after awhile it will get aggravating lol but when you get it you will be. Be very glad you have it. Good luck
I got today after about 5 tries more or less, with Treasure Hunter 1 & 2 + Thief Knife. I was basically very lucky that no one camps this, because the drop rate isn't too good. It seems like a nice piece to have for that level but nothing extraordinary. It's something nice for people to see when they examine you. Ofcourse, it's a very decent piece to use up until about level 30 When you get that sword with acc +3 and att+4 which I think is called Centurion's sword.
Anyways, I tested it out on regular mobs in Korroloka like spiders. The proc rate of the additional effect of poison is not too great. I still haven't checked if it's a powerful poison versus lower level mobs like Qufim ones (it's level 24, so it'll be used in that area or in level capped areas). Afterwards, I tested it on Aquans like fish to see if it had some sort of hidden effect, and the additional effect did not proct more, nor did I notice anything hidden. Lastly, I tested this on crabs in the area since this is dropped from a crab. I didn't notice more proc rate on crabs, nor did I notice any other hidden effect versus crabs.
im now the proud owner of this sword. i went 1/2 so after reading this i guess i got pretty lucky. first time i showed up and tried to solo him as a 36 bst/whm, got him down to just under 60% before he pwned me. came back later with a 75 thf friend and got the drop. ^^
Just a thought has anyone tried with 4-Leaf Mandragora Bud ?? i'm going to go try it in another 3 hours ^^ i guess i can report back if it works or not ^^ cheers M8's
Just to let you know, Nellihym, THF does not improve drop rates on Rare/ex items. Im 1/1 on this btw. Didn't know it was so rare. Its an awesome weapon for BLUs and the additional effect of poison hits pretty often.
Oh sorry. I've takenmany breaks from FFXI and i usually just learn the updates as i go...Must have been soon they confirmed this because before I took my 3rd break from FFXI in October 2007, some guy would always get on people in my LS about how TH doesn't work and stuff...
Always seems to be people with good drop rates for things and people with bad drop rates. iv known people who go 1/1 or 1/2 on nearly everything while iv had no rare/ex like bounding or hairpin and iv done abou 30kills on each knew 1 person who went 2/2 on hairpin to give to his friend.
me thinks that SE gives 4 out of 5 at the start of the game the cr*p drop spell that never will come off.
Hi all!!! Well currently 0/9 on the Nadrs. There are a few things I noticed that may help people. Although his pop time could be 1-3 hours, I am fairly convinced on the average is about 2hrs. You only have to kill the one clipper to the east or west of the bridge...the one sitting in the little pools. Respawn time of the clippers are about 10 to 13 mins. Rarely have I seen a 10 min respawn though. Typically I put my spells up in place at the 10 min. mark and it usually pops just before or just as my refresh wears...so typically 13 min.
I might be able to help with some of the truths and un-truths about Cargo Crab Cheapass. He did use his poison ability on me the very first one I fought...obviously no drop. He has never attempted it since then...I can say that if it happens its not 100% it will drop...but does it increase the odds...maybe...thats something I am still testing.
I have killed the Sea Monk 5 outta the 9 times...still spawned after 2hrs. Didn't seem to matter for him spawning or not. One thing I observed was that the Sea Monk did respawn shortly after CCC's pop. So I am testing now whether you kill the Sea Monk closer to the time of the pop that it will make a difference.
Doesn't seem to matter what pool the Greater Pugil is in. Cargo Crap Cheapass spawns in the area near the bridge every time I have killed it, never seen a pool spawn yet. Sometimes right on the bridge or next to each corresponding chasm on either side of the bridge and can be on the east or west side. So really in total you need to keep track of 5 spawn points...which is very easy.
He drops 1200 gil, 2 crab meat, & crab shell everytime I have killed him. Finally yes!!! he is miser(which is why my LS and myself have adopted his new name...lol)with his drops if you go 1/1 consider yourself very very lucky. I seriously am hoping the guy that wrote he went 1/40 was exaggerating...lol. Although I have only killed him nine times, I have seen 30+ spawns whether it be other campers or friends. From the other players that I have confirmed results it has dropped about 2 in 26 kills. Some players wouldn't acknowledge my inquiries so it may have dropped more. I have a feeling the drop rate is less than 10% though. Hope this information helps anyone looking for this awsome sword. I will update when I acquire accurate data.
***Edit*** Finally went 1/21 on the sword. I am convinced the Sea Monk does not have anything to do with Cargo spawning or not spawning. Cargo still spawn every time on time when he should have when the monk was dead or alive. Also the poison ability doesn't seem to make a difference in drop rate at all. In reality I believe there isn't anything "special" about Cargo...he seems to act just like every other pop NM in the game. He is just very boring to camp and I believe people notice things that aren't really anything to just occupy their mind. One thing true about him though is that his drop rate is filthy awful. From the data I got, I calculate the drop rate out to being roughly a little less than 5%.
1/2 on DRG/THF. I was down farming slimes one day a few months ago and CCC was up unclaimed. All on his lonesome. I'd camped him with a MNK friend of mine before, but we didn't get the drop for him (he was lvling BLU).
So I killed the little bugger and out pops a Nadrs. Suffice to say I'm pleasantly surprised. I was thinking of lvling BLU for DRG sub anyway, so I can't complain. It's a pretty sword. I've bazaared with it on using my WAR sub just because I could (what can I say? I'm easily contented.)
____________________________
Windurstian Galka Kujata Server LS: TheFireWithin Preferred Job: 75 DRG/WHM
Ok so i'm back... Last update i was 0/7, now i'm 0/10.
Only thing i have discovered is that killing the Sea Monk will stop CCC from spawning. Took me 4 friggin hours to figure this out. For those who can't put that together, if u kill Sea Monk he wont pop, or it will take an extremely long time to get pop.
And no drop, my friend THF70 or 69 or sumthin didn't get drop in 3 attempts... this is one greedy {Bastard Sword}.
____________________________
Stefilz -- Sitting: Away or not paying atention. -- Standing: Not paying atention. Send gil to Stefilz to help the "Equip Stefilz" fund. All donations are accepted 8 ). --http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?168223--
Currently I am 0/20 on Mr. Crab. We have become good friends over the past few weeks. Sometimes I have nothing else to do, that is when I say to my self "Hey self, I should go check in on my favorite crab, who knows today could be the day he is actually carrying cargo." Alas, it is never the day. I am beginning to hold the Nadrs in such high regard that it could possibly be a mythical weapon. I have almost forgotten the reason why I wanted this sword. Sure it looks cool and everything, but is it really worth it? Everyone should at least meet Colin once, but if he isn't generous and doesn't give you that 1/1 rate I would recommend finding another NM to be friends with. If you really want though, pop in after two hours from when you last saw him, check and see how he is doing and if he has anything for you. It may be a long and vicious cycle, but I know one day Mr. Crab will learn that I only think good thoughts of him, and he will be selfless enough to part with this treasure of his. Until that day, we will see each other quite often Colin. ^_^
hmm i'm slightly confused now, i am on the right amp and have been consistently killing the clippers...3 hours no and no CCC, also no jammer leeches in sight :/
1/7 on this, and made about 15k from the normal crab drops to boot :) finally got the bastard though, and it looks sooooooooooo sweet.
____________________________
God moves in extremely mysterious, not to say, circuitous ways. God does not play dice with the universe; He plays an ineffable game of His own devising, which might be compared, from the perspective of any of the other players, [ie., everybody.] to being involved in an obscure and complex version of poker in a pitch-dark room, with blank cards, for infinite stakes, with a Dealer who won't tell you the rules, and who smiles all the time. -Good Omens
Four of my LS members helped me camp Cargo Crab Colin last night. They were all ready to camp for up to 5 hours with me just to try and get a drop. ^^
Anyway, an hour in our LS leader comes running around the corner with just enough health to shout a "help!" before falling in battle. Trailing him are two Jammer Leeches!! I fall in suit right after him from like two hits, so does one other LS member, one runs around the corner out of range. Then our strongest LS member at the time returns from killing jellys to help us out.
Only an hour has passed since we have been there in the tunnel and the Jammers are slowly loosing life to our member. I start to scan the area behind me when BAM! Out pops good-ole Cargo!
I freak! I'm all dead and stuff, taking a dirt nap while he's casually walking over my carcus. I'm shouting in the party window, "POP!" and, "Cargo's here!!!"
Needless to say, we got claim. My LS member that is chopping away at the last Jammer remaining gives me a raise and the other LS member that survived follows suit and starts raising our other two fallen comrades.
We all attack Cargo with full force, he dies, and one try later-I have my Nadrs. ^^ Woot! 1/1!
What an eventfull night for me! Seeing that my hightest level is 23 WAR at the moment. ^^ Thanks LS members! DauntlessCrusaders for life!
P.S: If you are on Ramuh and want in on a really great group of FFXI people, join our LS! DauntlessCrusaders. Ask me, Maaruu, or Maomaox for a shell today! ^^
Good luck!
____________________________
In the word of the famous racecar Lightning McQueen: "Ka-Chow!"
Yea, just killed CCC and got the sword on my first kill, so freaking lucky, my heart is beating like crazy. This sword will look very nice on my 25 thf and 24 blu that i have to level! Now i just need to level blu to 40 so i can duel wield it with Immortals Scimitar.
To reiterate what others have said, yes the drop rate is horrendous. I killed CCC 10 times before he finally dropped the sword. I really wanted it because I love the design of the sword and it is the same model as the BLU AF sword, so you can dual wield them and look real bad ass.
On the bright side, you can farm Slime Oil while waiting on the 12 minute repop timer and make a few gil off that, and if you sub THF you can mug him for 500-1000K gil.
____________________________
"At any given time, the best FFXI player is the one who is having, and helping others have, the most fun" - Kiyokatsu
O/25 and counting, while I was farming slime oils over the last year or so. I've tried inviteing a thf for TH2, I've tried no ws, I've tried calling it and it's mother names, I've begged, I've threatened. What have I got? Some gil, a shell, and some crab meat. He just doesn't want to give me this sword.
I think that this is one of the best looking swords for its design. Just how it is a curved blade, we need more curved blades.
____________________________
Copyright WoW FTW! PVE till I'm used to WoW! "Butters, go buy World of Warcraft, install it on your computer and join the online sensation before we all murder you." - Cartman. "I like Hello Kitty: Island Sensation more..." -Butters
0/14 on this sucker. Thanks SE for making the drop rate of a low level rare/ex sword this bad... I saw some 50+ kill no drop posts at KI also. It seems SE didnt adjust the drop rate but f..... it /sigh
Edited, Sep 15th 2006 at 1:09pm EDT by Maderas
____________________________
ZM 6 ( Through the Quicksand Caves ) CoP 3-5 ( Darkness Named ) ToAU 12 ( Royal Puppeteer ) Tavnazia Access: O Whitegate Access: O
well this whole week i had to go to band for most of the day (huge drag) and so i decided to camp this NM because of my limited time online and everything... ive seen him 6 times about and claimed 4 of those times and got the sword :) 1/4 go me! srry to all u people with 0/12 and such... that must suck
Well my stats on this NM is as miserable as some, 0/8, 4 days wasted after work and the question I keep asking myself is WHY? Well it is a cool looking sword, and since my blu is 24 i figure why not. Now the pop rate is 2-3hrs, clipper in area is the place holder, and I usually farm the Water Elementals and Slime in area. 50 rdm/Rng, this is pretty simple NM, now my concern is once I get the sword drop, do you think I can get a 2nd to dual wield? Or am I just looking for pain?
slime oil going for 35k a stack and Water cluster 2k in jeuno each, i make pretty good gil even if I waste away trying for the drop. This of course in Queztlecoat server. Just make sure to leave the jammer Leeches alone until your 75 ish, got too bored one day and learned the hard way.
____________________________
My Stats are secret..... From the Quezle Baby!!!!! Ballista Anyone?? I'll show you how weak my Brd is... I'm Rich Bitch!!!!
Unfortunately you couldn't get a second to dual-wield anyhow, the Nadrs is Rare/Ex. Stick at it though, it's got a pretty nice DPS and cool look to boot. The poison is good fun, just be careful about using it on a mob that may have to be slept as it will cause problems.
____________________________
Catwho wrote:
Blame Tanaka! ♫ Blame Tanaka! ♫ He's not even a real dev anyway. ♫
First time took 3 hours, second time took 2.45, third time popped after first PH, and this last time that I just completed took 7 hours and 40 minutes to pop. I'm giving up now. I just wanted it for looks, but I could have already been way past the useful level for this damn sword. -_- I don't understand why SE would make an NM for a level 24 sword have such a crappy drop rate and Ullikummi-style pop conditions. ._.
I guess my TH2 is tired or something since I just helped a couple friends get empress hairpins and myself a pair of bounding boots. :\
If those stories under mine about 0/24 and whatever else are serious, just don't even bother with this sword. ._. It takes all of maybe a day to get from 24-28, and it's so not worth the grief and time wasted. I'll just push out my last three levels to mithran scimitar and deal with my dual flame swords on BLU. ;_;
Okay...so I'm clearly masochistic. -_- 0/5 now.
1/9...I couldn't give up for some reason. ._.;; Too bad I don't have that kind of patience for my acha d'armas and thief's knife. So...on my way to Kazham to pt and play with it on my blue mage. It's badass, but I still feel like stabbing myself when I realize I could probably be like 35+ blue mage by now. >.>
I heard about this sword and was planning on leveling blu in the future so I figured Id go check the spawn area before bed. No one else was there, saw a crab and killed it, 13 min. later NM pops and drops 2 meat, shell and sword. I put it in storage for later then went to bed.
This sword is fantastic. It looks incredible and is the best sword at the level by far, only the Auriga Xiphos compares, and my Dark Knight Dual wielding the 2 of them together is great. [ sword merits from paladin, if your wondering why i would be drk/nin mwahahaha ].
1/1 killed about 4 PH's in under a hour, wasnt really paying attention but yep got it easily 68mnk/thf used 2hr though just to get it done faster so i can lvl my blu
watersday waning gibbous 81%
____________________________
~TeeBone~ 75Mnk*37War*36Thf*34Rng*30Drg*27Whm*27Blm*24Blu* 16PldLS .-`Barkada`-. Bismark AF Complete 21Jan06 ^^ Maat Down 26Aug06 5:22
I just beat him today. Took about 2.5 hrs of camping for one pop. I counted the time from death of PH to the spawn of PH and found it to be 12 minutes. I beat him as Pld50/NIN18 (dont mind the gimped sub). it was very easy to recast utsusemi since he missed so much. he missed once about every 4-5 hits, and i have evasion -10. soo with a 12 minute respawn the wait isnt exactly exciting, but its pretty easy.
So... 12 minute respawn for the PH. He spawns in the water no matter what, but CCC didnt. His accuracy and damge were horrible. Hit me for 15-25 dmg and missed once every 4-5 trys. His defence is very high. I was doing 18-30 dmg until he used that Defence+ spell, which caused me to hit for 3-10.
Main thing for me was to keep utsusemi up as much as i could, and use Regen food. For a level 50 job i'd advise either /NIN or /WHM. That gives you your best chance of killing it easily.
Oh, and i didnt get the drop 8 (
____________________________
Stefilz -- Sitting: Away or not paying atention. -- Standing: Not paying atention. Send gil to Stefilz to help the "Equip Stefilz" fund. All donations are accepted 8 ). --http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?168223--
ok, i've goten him 6 more times now, still no drop.
CCC = 0/7
no idea if its just bad luck or maybe sumthin goin wrong, who knows >.<
____________________________
Stefilz -- Sitting: Away or not paying atention. -- Standing: Not paying atention. Send gil to Stefilz to help the "Equip Stefilz" fund. All donations are accepted 8 ). --http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?168223--
Having trouble gettting the drop, and some ppl think that this drop is very hard, I solo/duo this on my 60pld/war and my npc 32 fighter, but still no drops, ive heard that this nm isnt effected by TH or TH2 but I dont really understand, because TH and TH2 help recive rarer drops.....
____________________________
My Love and Life Snowkitty. Married a month ago, been together 5 months, and happy every second of them ^^
I just beat this thing solo with drg42/blu21. I used one pear au lait, enfeebled at the beginning with sprout smack and wild outs, kept cocoon up, and used power attack to trigger healing breath, and that's it really. He hit hard with cocoon down, but he missed alot. When he casts big scissors you get suck with a relatively powerful poison, but it didn't last long on me the three times he used it. And I didn't get the drop...probably going to try it again tommarow. I got 30-something xp so I would assume he is around level 35 or so, but I don't know how those calculations work.
Gearwise, I had elvaan RSE pants/hands/feet for mp, tiger stole, str+3 rings, red feathered cap :D, some underleveled scalemail, and AF lance. Food was rice dumplings. Oh and I had the auto-regen blu combo set.
Hope this helps any manly men with real strategies, not just those who run in there at 65+ and pansy it up.
I saw this sword on another random guy in Jeuno, then looked it up to see how to get it...so I decided to go for it.
64 Paladin/32 Warrior Bastard Sword & Temple Knight Army Shield +1 Everything else, my tanking gear.
I got there, and there were no clippers. About 5 minutes later, one spawned. I think someone was passing by and killed it or something. But About an hour later, killing clippers ever 13 minutes, he finally spawned. No one was around, so I didn't have to fight for claim. I provoked, and just didn't use any abilities like berserk or anything. He hit me for 9-30 damage. Averaging out around 15-20 damage. A critical hit, which he hit me for once, hit me for 51. I was doing 15-39 damage, and I crit him for 73. I was biding my time until I had 300TP. I cured (only required Cure III) to max health, and used Spirits Within for a grand total of 605 damage, which took him to about half life.
Long story short. Killed him with ease. He dropped this on the first try, as well as 1200 gil, 2 land crab meat, and a crab shell.
terrible... im 0/9 on it currently. The last kill was at a 95% moon phase too. Honestly don't get yourself wrapped up in this guy. Now that i've wasted 3 days there i would feel dumb stopping without my sword. you on the otherhand havent even started. Preserve your sanity and pretend it doesnt exist
I went through the same thing. I decided to try for webcutter later on, and saw CCC had popped once again. This time he decided to drop the sword. 1/10 :D
Got this last night for my BLU I went 0/7 previously on it then I decided to camp it again. Waited 6 hours for him to pop.....6....HOURS!!
Anyways he pops..I get him..get drop. ^_^
____________________________
.::WoW::. Retired Daemonxel 80 Orc Deathknight -moonrunner Calenture 80 UD Lock -moonrunner Korvinus 80 BE Rogue -moonrunner .::FFXI::. DRK 75 BLM 75 BLU 75 | LoA Retired Sylph server NEVER A TRUER STATEMENT MADE: "It's always NA time in WoW."
Got this item long ago for my THF, but checked it again last night (after the ToAU release). This sword is also equippable by Blue Mages. Which makes perfect sense and makes this cool but otherwise useless sword useful :-)
Well I'd like to start off by saying I have terrible luck on NMs.. 1/52 on Lizzy. I was in Korroloka farming slime oil, I was bored and wandered around. I came upon a pond and saw a clipper there, reminded me of some crab NM being there so I looked it up. Found out I was actually at the spawn area, decided why not? Killed the crab. To kill time I trained all the bats and the pugil and the sea monk in the area. Took me a good 6 mins to clear all those as 72whm/23nin dual wielding darksteel mauls and having a buncha attack gear (didn't use any tp, was saving for crab). CCC Popped during this escapade, luckily noone was around. I finished the bats off at my leisure and claimed him. He has, I must say, probably the worst accuracy of any mob ever. I think I've been hit more often by mandies outside of windy. But he has pretty good defense. My attack was 304 and I was hitting him for 20ish damage. Did Hexa strike whenever I got TP, each hit for about 160... was a pretty drawn out fight, thought about divine nuking him but I was curious to see if my Utsu and Stoneskin would last the fight lol. Eventually he took out my Utsu, I'm not sure if he broke my Stoneskin or it gave out from boredom lol but stoneskin went down and he was hitting me for about 30-50 @ 228 def (hadnt bothered casting protect). Dropped the sword thingy, I guess if I level thief again I'll try this. Orz for being 1/1, if it's any consolation I saw the noob lizzy campers get drop on first try and almost threw tv out the window lol.
Edited, Sat Mar 11 05:48:32 2006
____________________________
Square Enix wrote:
We have received reports that a popular third-party FINAL FANTASY XI website had been infecting customers with malicious software...
We suggest that our customers read up on precautionary measures they can take to ensure the safety of their information online.
Square Enix, a company who cares... about your money.
Lynna the Red Mage I ran out of funny stuff to put here a long time ago. I blame alcohol, bad leadership, and the eyes of others. Also, BOLLOCKS. I rest my case.
Seriously, all the stories im hearing about guys getting this on first try lately is pissing me off, i camped him like crazy about a year ago, went 0/25 on him. I seriously beleive SE has altered the drop rate, infact the picture shown on here for the equip menu is different then it was. Probably altered with the patch, gonna camp it again and try my luck.