1

Love and Ice  

Realm:Bastok
Start Area: Port Bastok
Start NPC:Carmelo (E - 6)
Type:General
Prerequisites:A Test of True Love
The Siren's Tear
The Stars of Ifrit
Related Areas:Beaucedine Glacier
Min Level:1
Max Level:75
Rating
*****
(From 1 rating)
Title Obtained:Sorrow Drowner
Items Granted:Lamia Harp
Last Updated: Thu Aug 4 13:42:04 2005

Contents [hide]

Summary

Carmelo wants to start his life anew. You must go throw the song sheet he had written for his former love into the Mirror Lake on the Beaucedine Glacier.

Walkthrough

You must have completed The Stars of Ifrit quest before you can begin this quest.

Prior to accepting the quest, you must also examine the key item Carrier Pigeon Letter which is acquired as part of the prerequisite quest. Once you've done so, talk to Carmelo and he will give you the key item Carmelo's Song Sheet.

Examine the Mirror Pond at Beaucedine Glacier (G-10) on a clear day (no snow falling) to receive a cutscene. You can't ride a chocobo through Beaucedine Glacier, and mobs will aggro characters as high as level 50, so characters no higher than that will require some form of Sneak and Invisible.

When you return to Carmelo, he will reward you with a Lamia Harp. Provided you have sufficient fame, if you zone out and zone back in, Carmelo will give you the next quest in the series, A Test of True Love.

Quest Series

This quest is part of a series of quests offered by Agapito and Carmelo in Port Bastok. See the list below to find out which quest comes next.

This page last modified 2008-09-14 18:26:46.
Send a correction
Post Comment
I'm a dumb ass
# Jul 06 2006 at 10:45 AM Rating: Decent
*
145 posts
I spent a few hours at the other mirror pown at like j-5ish around fei-yin. Got ****** off when glow and no snow and stuff guess it shows A read and B SE is confusing.
The final truth
# Feb 19 2006 at 9:48 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
35 posts
No... the G-10 pond is the correct one. I just completed the quest.

Quote:
* It's extremely rare for the Beaucedine Glacier to have clear weather, as most of the time it is snowing. Check with the weather forcaster Maleme for info on what the weather will be like in the Glacier for the next three days (three earth hours.) She's in South San d'Oria at J-8.


The pond at G-10 has a target with a blank description window. But, if you are there on a clear day or dark weather day IN THE DAYTIME - meaning between 6:00 and 18:00 game day, another target point will spawn - 'Mirror Pond'. It will appear to the left of the blank target so just run there and hit it for a cutscene.

I hope this clarifies things a bit.
____________________________
Do not try to change me for I am true to myself.
If you wish for me to change, prove me your worth.
------------------
Woodworking: 72.1
Fishing: 76.4

Lu Shang's Fishing Rod: obtained 27. 3. 2006
RE: The final truth
# Mar 02 2006 at 7:37 PM Rating: Decent
10 posts
I was actually able to get the cutscene by touching the Mirror Pond at 23:06 in dark weather, so it doesn't have to be dark weather in the daytime.

Edited, Thu Mar 2 18:35:15 2006
____________________________
Virtus - Male Hume - Ramuh - Bastok - Rank 10
WAR37 = MNK75 = PLD73 = SAM37 = DRG37
THF37 = NIN37
Linkshells: SurvivorsAll
three ponds 1 cutscene
# Feb 14 2006 at 7:03 PM Rating: Decent
*
65 posts
ok

I still need to try that -.-
nice trick by the way, how did you figuer it out?

i was there on a dark day, ****...let it pass me too! lol

i found my cofferkey FOR MY af3 QUEST.^^ (PldLVL56~57)

Edited, Wed Mar 15 01:02:04 2006
____________________________
Quote:
When ever there's suffering, I'll be there... Where ever there's injustice, I'll take up arms... If there's no pty to be found and you're pulling every hair from the top of your head to make that extra xp point, extra gil or find that rare "Drop"... you can count on PSX to make it better. Smiley: boozing


Paladin75 Thief36 Samerai60 Monk21 Beastmaster21 Ranger10 Warrior37 White Mage33 Black Mage7 Summoner12 Ninja26 Dragoon24 !! Dnc !!











Dark Element
# Dec 02 2005 at 3:58 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
181 posts
Ice+Double Ice didn't let the Mirror Pond spawn. Single Dark Element did. That is all.
____________________________
PLD75
BLM75
MNK54
Siren's Tear quest
# Feb 23 2005 at 11:06 AM Rating: Decent
The Siren's Tear quest is apparently a prerequisite for this. I did the quest for Agapito, examined the letter key item before and after completing it. Carmelo just mentioned "a Siren's Tear" (in green text) going down a river, tides of war or something. I waited several days including one conquest tally and he still didn't provide the quest. After looking up the Siren's Tear quest and completing it for Wahid, Carmelo gave me this quest.

Has anyone else experienced this situation?
____________________________
No longer playing FFXI.
RE: Siren's Tear quest
# Aug 05 2005 at 2:51 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
158 posts
Once you do this quest, it will become very apparent why you need to have done the Siren's Tear quest before. The jewel is mentioned in cutscenes... it's important to the relationship between Carmelo and Daliah. Especially how each of them thought it affected things...
RE: Pertinent info
# Dec 17 2004 at 2:00 PM Rating: Default
*
60 posts
I have compleated "The Stars of Ifrit" quest, and i Talk to Carmelo and did not obtain the key item: Carmelo's Song Sheet.
i have rank 6 and no go, What's my prob?
RE: Pertinent info
# Jan 13 2005 at 7:45 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
100 posts
Rank doesn't matter. City Fame matters. Build up your Bastok fame by doing lower quests, then you can do the highers ones.
Read the Letter
# Oct 13 2004 at 1:46 AM Rating: Excellent
**
374 posts
I was having the same issue as Mecorx. Just finished it, left the zone, came back, and Carmelo wouldn't talk to me. I examined the key item: a carrier pigeon letter. Clicked on Carmelo again and voila, cut scene.

Venka
____________________________
Kainan - 300 Alchemy, 276 Hammersmith
Nutaris - 300 Tailoring, 300 Enchanting
Bhati - 300 Skinning, 300 Tribal Leathercraft
Biako - 300 Dragonscale Leathercraft, 275 Skinning
huh?
# Aug 23 2004 at 6:04 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,534 posts
I think this guide is not completely right, i finished stars of ifrit zoned, and zoned back in and talked to Carmelo, He did not give me a quest, all he said was "my name, on some love letter? are you sure? there must be some mistake.
So you DO need fame for this quest
____________________________
[ffxivsig]346334[/ffxivsig]
Mecorx - Ifrit 75WAR/75WHM [Retired]
RE: huh?
# Sep 06 2004 at 8:37 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
915 posts
Two possible causes:
A) You already have the key item (I'm pretty sure I got it without realizing it was for the next quest, I'll have to check)
B) You don't have enough fame for this second quest.
____________________________
~ EQ2: Locano on Antonia Bayle ~
65 Wizard / 65 Sage
~ FFXI: Locano on Valefor ~
75 RDM / 60 BLM / 50 WHM / 37 NIN / 37 DRK / 20 THF / 19 WAR / 17 SMN
LiveJournal / Rank 10 Bastokan / Rank 8 Windurstian
Kinda confusing
# Aug 09 2004 at 3:40 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
57 posts
When you go to the lake there is a blank ??? and then one that says Mirror Pond. Make sure you click on the Mirror Pond one. It's on the back side of the lake. You can do this when it's 'gloomy', darkness element.
____________________________
Character: Swenny
Nationality: Windurst
Rank: 10
Server: Carbuncle
Linkshell: ProphecyReborn
BLM75/SMN55/RDM41/WHM39/NIN37/BST30
THF30/BRD25/DRK20/MNK20/PLD20/WAR20
BLU13/DRG13/COR8/SAM8/RNG5/PUP1
Retribution: O Black Halo: O

"You really can't go wrong with FFI. No seriously!"
Thanks Valyana
# Jul 19 2004 at 2:39 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
36 posts
Great tip there Val, I was baffled.. was Rank 9 fame in Bastok (Master Rcade! You are a hero to the people of Bastok! Everyone here knows your name and what you've done for us! You are the example every Bastoker should follow!), had done Ifrit's tear and Cid's Secret and STILL couldn't get it. Examining that letter seems to be a MUST.
____________________________
Rcade - Unicorn - http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?20449
yup
# Apr 02 2004 at 1:49 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,221 posts
i read the letter and got the quest

thx!
____________________________
Deadmeat - Caitsith
Bastokan Hume, Rank 10, ZM complete, CoP complete
FFXI complete

"Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side and a dark side, and it binds the universe together."
Read the letter
# Mar 29 2004 at 1:34 PM Rating: Good
**
787 posts
I needed to examine the "Carrier pigeon letter" key item before Carmelo would give me this quest.


Edited, Mon Apr 19 02:57:49 2004
____________________________
Valyana of Ramuh || BRD profile || BST combat profile
fame level?
# Mar 23 2004 at 10:00 AM Rating: Decent
****
4,221 posts
i can't get this quest.

I've done Star of Ifrit and Siren's Tear and I have the Titan quest.
____________________________
Deadmeat - Caitsith
Bastokan Hume, Rank 10, ZM complete, CoP complete
FFXI complete

"Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side and a dark side, and it binds the universe together."
Prereqs?
# Mar 20 2004 at 2:50 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
277 posts
I wonder if the Siren's Tear quest is also a prereq for this quest, since Carmelo is the NPC that tells you how to collect it (and he mentions that he was forced to sell it in the dialog). If you think you have enough fame and have met the other requirements and still don't receive this quest, it might be worth a shot to see if completing the Siren's Tear quest will let you have it.
____________________________

Cymmina
Avatars Defeated: Ramuh, Ifrit, Titan, Garuda, Leviathan
Ready to Defeat: Shiva
Challenging the old fashioned way!
RE: Prereqs?
# Jan 10 2005 at 1:26 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
73 posts
yes, the Siren's Tear quest is also a prerequisite to this quest.
Dark Element
# Mar 19 2004 at 3:13 PM Rating: Decent
You can examine the mirror pond when Beaucedine Glacier has the dark element.
____________________________
Gatts
Pertinent info
# Mar 19 2004 at 2:40 AM Rating: Excellent
Guru
**
258 posts
* You need to have at least level 5 fame in Bastok before Carmelo will start this quest; otherwise he just refuses to admit that he wrote the note from the previous quest. At level 5 fame, Flaco by the tavern tells you, "A lot of people know what you've done for Bastok. People are saying good things about you. Keep up the good work!"

* It's extremely rare for the Beaucedine Glacier to have clear weather, as most of the time it is snowing. Check with the weather forcaster Maleme for info on what the weather will be like in the Glacier for the next three days (three earth hours.) She's in South San d'Oria at J-8.

* Although the reward for this isn't that great, it is a fairly easy quest if you arrive during a clear day. This quest is a prerequisite for two more quests from Carmelo, as well.
____________________________
ffxi.cannotlinkto -- All FFXI facts, all the time.
RE: Pertinent info
# May 20 2004 at 1:06 AM Rating: Default
Scholar
**
715 posts
And what quests would these be, as they obviously aren't posted on the site ^^
____________________________
Agrorthal -- Level 60MNK/30WAR/15THF/11BLM/11WHM -- Galka -- Rank 6 -- Seraph

Lahtrorgo -- Level 17 Dwarf Paladin -- Kal'Thuzad

Agror's Guide to Vana'diel - Updated 8/24
RE: Pertinent info
# Jun 30 2004 at 7:58 AM Rating: Good
**
334 posts
I would also like to know. I have fame level 6 and Carmelo does not give me any more quests.
____________________________
Daleth
Caitsith
RE: Pertinent info
# Jul 18 2004 at 6:37 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
132 posts
"A Test of True Love" and "Lovers in the Dusk"
____________________________
Server: {Cerberus}
Profiles: {Thief/Ninja} ~ [yellow]{Ninja/Warrior}
Post Comment

Free account required to post

You must log in or create an account to post messages.