Xilk wrote:
Except your are dead wrong. Its just as true in a Japanese company as a western one.
My what is dead wrong?
UltKnightGrover wrote:
To the people talking about the high-ups possibly overturning Tanaka's decisions, Tanaka wasn't just an ordinary producer. He was head of the whole Product Development Division, the whole sector of Square Enix that made part of the FF franchise. He was the successor of Sakaguchi to carry on the FF-name, as Yoshinori Kitase and Hiroyuki Ito were selected as well.
He was also Senior Vice President of Software Development.
Now if you're saying all of those positions he had had no say in the company or the products it was releasing, then that says something strong about Square-Enix as a whole.
He was also Senior Vice President of Software Development.
Now if you're saying all of those positions he had had no say in the company or the products it was releasing, then that says something strong about Square-Enix as a whole.
This is what people fail to take into account. He wasn't just "some producer" that's had a position of tenure. He helped to start the damned franchise and was part of their original planning team. The man was part of the crew that helped to build the company! So yes, despite how many of you want to say his hands were tied really don't look at how Japanese businesses are run. Wada joined the company over a decade later and despite being CEO did not want to step on his toes.
You people also forget that Tanaka allowed FFXI to launched as bug ridden, little content, and coasted on the fact that it was Final Fantasy. He did this with RoZ, CoP, ToAU, WotG (many seem to want to forget how long it actually took for an expansion to actually be more than job unlocking, two or three missions, and a handful of quests), and it finally came back to bite him in the ass when he tried it with FFXIV. He depended on the mentality that gamers would accept "It's just an MMO, it can be patched later, it's Final Fantasy after all!" and it was a very, very poor judgement call.
As far as his health is concerned, many foot massages and back rubs off to the man. He was part of the crew that gave me Final Fantasy I/IV and Secret of Mana and I'll always thank the wanker for those timeless classics. If his health does end up doing a turnaround and he goes to work with Sakaguchi then I'll gladly try a game provided that he has absolutely zero input in the battle system planning.








