1
Forum Settings
       
This thread is locked

Eureka! A temporary solution found! (not a lame post).Follow

#1 Mar 12 2007 at 6:16 PM Rating: Decent
Actually someone mentioned this before and I decided to try it out. My PS2 shares a connection with this PC through my router. I disconnected my router and plugged my CAT-5 cable directly to my cable modem. I was able to get into the game finally.

For those of you with similar set-ups I hope this works. Good luck.

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 10:52pm by Pikko
#2 Mar 12 2007 at 6:52 PM Rating: Decent
Living on a Prayer
******
30,114 posts
Sadly, people don't want to hear that the problem could very well be on their side.
Yes yes, I recognize that the problem didn't start until the update. Of course the update has something to do with it.
The solution is going to be different for everyone I'm sure.
This isn't the first time I've read about someone who took their router out of the equation and it fixes their problem.

Perhaps it would be helpful if in one of these many threads, everyone gets together and posts what their set up is like.
As in:
whether or not you're having issues
What your ISP is
Where in the world you live
The manufacturer/model of your modem
The manufacturer/model of your router and what version of the firmware it's running
surely a common element could be pulled out of this.


Edited, Mar 12th 2007 9:55pm by Usagichan
#3 Mar 12 2007 at 6:59 PM Rating: Default
Quote:
Sadly, people don't want to hear that the problem could very well be on their side.


Sadly, some people will say/do whatever to protect their beloved SE.

I'm sorry but when thousands of users are suddenly kicked off FFXI, and SE says their **** is working perfect.

We have a problem. And it's not us.

Btw, I do not have connection problems, so my post isn't biased.
#4 Mar 12 2007 at 7:03 PM Rating: Decent
Vagina Dentata,
what a wonderful phrase
******
30,106 posts
I haven't had any connectivity problems since that slow assed update.
____________________________
Turin wrote:
Seriously, what the f*ck nature?
#5 Mar 12 2007 at 7:06 PM Rating: Decent
and then there are the people who like to bash SE for anything bad that happens without even thinking that it might not be SE's fault.

if everyone in a particular region (RL) were having trouble or certain areas were inaccessable to EVERYONE, then i might consider that it is something on SE's side. But, becuase not everyone is having trouble, and there does not seem to be any pattern to those having trouble, i am inclined to believe it is either a software problem, a hardware problem (as in, an update unintnentionaly caused certain program and/or hardware combos to glitch out), or a problem somewhere between the user and SE.

There is also the fact that data is still being sent.

Also, please don't say that people are blindly defending SE. because if you are someone that jumps in and blames SE att any chance, it is likely that you cant tell when someone is just making an observation, because blaming SE is normal to you. so please, realise that not everyone that is defending SE is a fanboy.
#6 Mar 12 2007 at 7:27 PM Rating: Excellent
*
117 posts
To the OP:

Here's what I think happened in your case.

Bypassing your router, you exposed the MAC adress of your network card (PC or your PS2 - I wasn't clear which you use for FFXI) to your IPS (instead of the MAC address of your route). Changing MAC addresses will "confuse" the DHCP server (the server that assigns you an IP address) and it will assign you a different IP address.

Serveral users including myself have found that the issue is apparently IP address dependent. Though everyone seems to get differnt results. For some it seems to fix it, others like me just get a different set of problems, and some others don't see any change.

Hope this is helpful to someone.
#7 Mar 13 2007 at 12:11 PM Rating: Good
*
201 posts
alphamone wrote:
and then there are the people who like to bash SE for anything bad that happens without even thinking that it might not be SE's fault.


i agree that there is a problem with people that automatically blame SE for problems without trying to think for themself about what's happening.

However, after 3+ years of dealing with FFXI and SE's particular version of "customer support" it's completly understandable.


Quote:

if everyone in a particular region (RL) were having trouble or certain areas were inaccessable to EVERYONE, then i might consider that it is something on SE's side. But, becuase not everyone is having trouble, and there does not seem to be any pattern to those having trouble, i am inclined to believe it is either a software problem, a hardware problem (as in, an update unintnentionaly caused certain program and/or hardware combos to glitch out), or a problem somewhere between the user and SE.


The problem is, everything worked fine before the update, and things were broken after the update (I can't even complete the update for my PS2 and that's after SE announced that the inability to update problem was fixed).

Adding to this, some people can login, do lots of things, and then hit a zone and then they R0. They login to a mule, and it's a different zone.. or works without problems. Somebody else playing in their house on the SAME network has no problem. After saying things like that to their support center staff, the only answer is "our servers are fine, try again later". It's almost as if that's the only thing they are able to say for any problem anybody has.

I initially gave SE the benefit of the doubt, but after trying to talk their "customer support" people, I fully understand why some people won't do that. Their condiscending and dismissive attitude is part of the problem people have with them. If you haven't run into that with them, then either you haven't read their annoucements or you haven't had to call (or email) their support center for an issue that's not on their scripted list of replies.

Try and ask them a question (any question), see what kind or response you get. They have people like "sage sundi" as an official spoksman, and many of the answers he has given have been wrong or so vague that it's useless.. This general lack of understanding and knowledge is common within the playonline support center.

2 years ago I had an issue with the people at the support center telling me to look at online guides or websites for information about FFXI. I said repeatedly that if I wanted to read 10,000 other users playing psychic detective with questions about FFXI, I would have done that instead of looking for answers from playonline (sounds like what's happening now, doesn't it?). I asked why the japanese market had some really interesting guide books (put out by SE) and the NA market got a incomplete guide from bradygames filled with mistakes. After generating 9 different ticket numbers in their trouble support tracking system, and being told that somebody from management would call me (never happened), I finally got an email from "Lyman Tuttle" stating: "Dynamis is functioning as intended" and that "no further information on this issue would be available to me".

In this instance, I was NOT asking about dynamis, I was asking why I couldn't get support from playonline without being told to look somewhere else. I asked why when I called the support center, I was told I had to send email, and when I sent email the reply was call the support center.. putting me into a loop. The only answer I could get about this support loop was "dynamis is just fine, go away now". They could have told me that it was time I changed the oil in my car and it would have been more helpful.

The way SE is dealing with this current problem (and apparently all problems) hasn't improved or changed in over 2 years.

Quote:

Also, please don't say that people are blindly defending SE. because if you are someone that jumps in and blames SE att any chance, it is likely that you cant tell when someone is just making an observation, because blaming SE is normal to you. so please, realise that not everyone that is defending SE is a fanboy.


Because that's exacly what people do. They defend SE without even reading the whole thread or they suggest that the people complaing are nothing but trolls beating a dead horse and they need to get tinfoil hats. Fanboy or not, with answers like that to questions they could work for playonline's customer support center (maybe they already do...).

I've worked in major helpdesk phone support before. We had a client base of over 180,000 users. I know what can and does happen after a major system outage. I know what happens when there's a major system outage that is not our fault, and we can't fix. If I had given answers like the ones I (and others) have been getting from SE. it would have ended my employment. With SE it's just business as usual.


#8 Mar 13 2007 at 12:23 PM Rating: Good
Everyone blames SE.

How come I've only seen one person, in all of these posts, suggest that it may be the telecommunications company that SE is using? (Granted, there's no way in Hell I've read every last one, but the dichotomy of this ongoing argument seems to be Squenix vs. certain ISPs...)

The sooner that we, the player base, can test every possible hypothesis, the sooner we can relay that information to Squenix assuming they don't figure it out themselves.
#9 Mar 13 2007 at 1:11 PM Rating: Decent
Up until the update everything worked perfectly.
+
Now I am unable to acquire server data
=
I don't see how there is an argument of whose fault it is.
#10 Mar 13 2007 at 1:26 PM Rating: Good
Regardless.... We pay for a service and are unable to use it. In my mind i don't care who's fault it is, I just want some kind of solution.

If time warner's cable goes out for more than one day and I call them. I don't care if its out of their control, I.E. Power outage on their end, they either refund my service or compensate me in some other way. Thats good customer service as I am paying for it and deserve to get something for the money I pay.

The fact that SE is pushing blame on others is crappy but they could at least compensate us. I haven't been able to play for 5 days now. And all they can say is were looking into it. GREAT customer service.

Then as if thats not bad enough, some people want to post and act like its not a big deal. Like we shouldn't be blaming SE. blah blah blah. Why is it that its the people that are still getting the service they pay for? Just out of curiosity who should we blame if not SE? The telecomm people they use? And if that is the case why would we do that? We pay SE NOT the telecomm people.





#11 Mar 13 2007 at 1:27 PM Rating: Good
*
201 posts
firefeng wrote:

The sooner that we, the player base, can test every possible hypothesis, the sooner we can relay that information to Squenix assuming they don't figure it out themselves.



Uh.. wait.. what? We're supposed to test every possible hypothesis? Since when did we sign up to start working as SE's tech support group?

I'm all for testing things that might help, but once you try 5 different ISPs, 5 different network setups and 2 different systems (ps2/windows), there isn't much else that can be done. Even if it was a japanese ISP that SE uses, it's still SE's responsibility, not the player base.

It's that line of thinking that has lead to SE's complete lack of Tech support. They don't need to provide that kind of service because the player base will do it for them. We don't expect that kind of response from any of our other service providers (TV, electric, power, gas, water).. why should we accept it from SE? I'm not saying a video game is as important as those things, but that shouldn't absolve SE of responsibility to it's customers. Nobody suggests when the phone goes out that I start climbing poles in the neighborhood to find the problem.. why is that answer accepted in this situation?

Even when I called them and tried to talk to their support people, they didn't care about any of the testing I had done. Which i did to rule out my equipment/network, before I called them. They couldn't (or wouldn't) see past "our servers are working". Telling the userbase that they have to test every possible hypothesis is almost admitting SE isn't going to look for an answer..

oh wait....


#12 Mar 13 2007 at 1:30 PM Rating: Decent
"The sooner that we, the player base, can test every possible hypothesis, the sooner we can relay that information to Squenix assuming they don't figure it out themselves."

And why would I test this hypothesis? I'm not a technician being paid by SE to fix this problem. As I matter of fact I think at this point I'm inadvertently paying to help them fix the problem since the service I'm paying for is nonexistent.
#13 Mar 13 2007 at 1:32 PM Rating: Decent
Amen randommule!
#14 Mar 13 2007 at 1:40 PM Rating: Good
***
2,430 posts
itsbutters wrote:
Quote:
Sadly, people don't want to hear that the problem could very well be on their side.


Sadly, some people will say/do whatever to protect their beloved SE.

I'm sorry but when thousands of users are suddenly kicked off FFXI, and SE says their sh*t is working perfect.

We have a problem. And it's not us.

Btw, I do not have connection problems, so my post isn't biased.


When more than thousands of users are suddenly still able to play FFXI, I would say it's wroking perfect too.

Can you -prove- it's them, other than just saying "They released an update, it has to be their side"? You can't. the problem is UNKNOWN for a reason. Unless it can be pinpointed, you can't lay blame on sides.
#15 Mar 13 2007 at 1:44 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,430 posts
Ninjapiratecombo wrote:
Up until the update everything worked perfectly.
+
Now I am unable to acquire server data
=
I don't see how there is an argument of whose fault it is.


Their Servers worked fine before hte update.
+
Now their servers are still working fine.
=
I dont see either.
#16 Mar 13 2007 at 1:45 PM Rating: Decent
**
261 posts
Ninjapiratecombo wrote:
Up until the update everything worked perfectly.
+
Now I am unable to acquire server data
=
I don't see how there is an argument of whose fault it is.


Up until the update, everything worked perfectly.
+
Now i am still able to do everything i could before.
=
I don't see how there's an argument of whose fault it is.
--------------

You see, the interesting aspect with that arguement, is that it's not EVERYONE who's having the problems. I'm certainly not. I can log in just fine, and can get around all of Vanadiel with no r0 issues.

If you go to bed with a light that works, and wake up to find a light that doesn't, it doesn't mean your power was shut off. You might just need to change a lightbulb.
#17 Mar 13 2007 at 1:48 PM Rating: Decent
swish wrote:
Ninjapiratecombo wrote:
Up until the update everything worked perfectly.
+
Now I am unable to acquire server data
=
I don't see how there is an argument of whose fault it is.


Up until the update, everything worked perfectly.
+
Now i am still able to do everything i could before.
=
I don't see how there's an argument of whose fault it is.
--------------

You see, the interesting aspect with that arguement, is that it's not EVERYONE who's having the problems. I'm certainly not. I can log in just fine, and can get around all of Vanadiel with no r0 issues.

If you go to bed with a light that works, and wake up to find a light that doesn't, it doesn't mean your power was shut off. You might just need to change a lightbulb.


And when u pay for a service you cannot receive especially when it has nothing to do with something the user has done, as is this case, you should be refunded. BBB anyone?
#18 Mar 13 2007 at 1:56 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,430 posts
So if i install FFXI on my old crappy *** PC, and it doesn't work, i should be refunded too?
#19 Mar 13 2007 at 2:01 PM Rating: Good
Usagichan wrote:
Sadly, people don't want to hear that the problem could very well be on their side.
Yes yes, I recognize that the problem didn't start until the update. Of course the update has something to do with it.
The solution is going to be different for everyone I'm sure.
This isn't the first time I've read about someone who took their router out of the equation and it fixes their problem.

Perhaps it would be helpful if in one of these many threads, everyone gets together and posts what their set up is like.
As in:
whether or not you're having issues
What your ISP is
Where in the world you live
The manufacturer/model of your modem
The manufacturer/model of your router and what version of the firmware it's running
surely a common element could be pulled out of this.


Usagichan just became the voice of reason, the end is nigh.
#20 Mar 13 2007 at 2:01 PM Rating: Good
**
261 posts
Supraz wrote:
And when u pay for a service you cannot receive especially when it has nothing to do with something the user has done, as is this case, you should be refunded. BBB anyone?


And yet, as has been stated, there is also no evidence this is SE related.

There are multiple people with r0 issues, and multiple people without r0 issues. And, i'm willing to bet that the majority are those without r0 issues.

So, to respond; When you pay for a service you cannot recieve especially when it has nothing to do with something the provider has done, in this case, you should NOT be refunded.


There is no blanket cause to the issues people are having. But, the aren't my problem, as i'm not having said issues. That alone should tell you it's not likely caused by something on SE's end. Primarily because if it were, i would be having r0 problems as well.

Perhaps the solution is as simple as changing a lightbulb... but alas, SE can't go into your home to do it... you must be smart enough to figure it out yourself.

That reminds me of a joke... How many FFXI players does it take to change a lightbulb? None, it's SE's fault.

*i forgot to put in the punchline.

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:03pm by swish
#21 Mar 13 2007 at 2:02 PM Rating: Decent
Or you could reread my post..... I do believe I said.....


"And when u pay for a service you cannot receive especially when it has nothing to do with something the user has done, as is this case, you should be refunded."

Key part being "when it has nothing to do with something the user has done"

If you installed it on a crappy laptop and it wouldn't work your fault

If some unreliable router in Japan goes down or gets hosed not your fault.

People like you are just here to agitate people.

Heres your sign.
#22 Mar 13 2007 at 2:06 PM Rating: Good
swish wrote:
Supraz wrote:
And when u pay for a service you cannot receive especially when it has nothing to do with something the user has done, as is this case, you should be refunded. BBB anyone?


And yet, as has been stated, there is also no evidence this is SE related.

There are multiple people with r0 issues, and multiple people without r0 issues. And, i'm willing to bet that the majority are those without r0 issues.

So, to respond; When you pay for a service you cannot recieve especially when it has nothing to do with something the provider has done, in this case, you should NOT be refunded.


There is no blanket cause to the issues people are having. But, the aren't my problem, as i'm not having said issues. That alone should tell you it's not likely caused by something on SE's end. Primarily because if it were, i would be having r0 problems as well.

Perhaps the solution is as simple as changing a lightbulb... but alas, SE can't go into your home to do it... you must be smart enough to figure it out yourself.

That reminds me of a joke... How many FFXI players does it take to change a lightbulb..........



On other thing before I leave work.... It amazes me how much people like to talk about things they know nothing about. This is clearly a routing problem somewhere which would explain tracerts timing out, only certain people being effected. They can come to my house and change all the light bulbs they want but thats not going to solve the problem. And what makes u think that some 2000+ plus people all the sudden did something at the same time that is effecting their game play? How likely is that? and if Comcast has a router in its path to my house that my data hops through for my digital cable, and it goes down...... they refund me EVEN if they DONT own that router.

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:07pm by Supraz

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:09pm by Supraz

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:12pm by Supraz
#23 Mar 13 2007 at 2:15 PM Rating: Decent
**
686 posts
Occam's razor FTW

The only things in common with everyone that is getting R0 is

A. They play FFXI
B. They updated FFXI
C. They are getting jerked around by SE not taking the blame.

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:16pm by dniheb
#24 Mar 13 2007 at 2:19 PM Rating: Decent
**
437 posts
firefeng wrote:
How come I've only seen one person, in all of these posts, suggest that it may be the telecommunications company that SE is using? (Granted, there's no way in Hell I've read every last one, but the dichotomy of this ongoing argument seems to be Squenix vs. certain ISPs...)


Because it's up to SE to contact, and work with their ISP to ensure they are not the issue. It's not up to us, the players.
#25 Mar 13 2007 at 2:27 PM Rating: Decent
From what I have been reading and experiencing myself over the past week or so, I would take an educated guess that this connectivity issue is neither SE's or our faults. I believe this a problem resulting to thier ISP trying to handle the downloads of the thousands upon thousands of people downloading the huge update. I think something got screwed up with thier ISP trying to handle the high bandwith of the large download and possibly corrupting some of them.

As for thier way of handling customer support, I really think this is the difference in cultures and countries. They have a way of doing things and people in Europe and North America have a way of doing things. Flame me for this all you want I dont care about my ranking on here (whoo hoo). For the record I am having connectivity issues across four characters on two worlds, and I would like to see this fixed also ASAP, so as you can see I am not being biased, but just putting 2+2 together with the evidence that has been brought fourth.


So in conlusion I think SE should get ther head out of thier [Back] [Side] and maybe switch thier ISP that brings the game out to Europe and North America


<br>And that was my 2 cents


*edited for clarity and a few typos*

Edited, Mar 13th 2007 6:30pm by sephyder
This thread is locked
You cannot post in a locked topic!
Recent Visitors: 354 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (354)