1
Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Powerleveling - the Ethical WayFollow

#1 Aug 25 2005 at 3:02 PM Rating: Good
**
376 posts
This post is one I made in another forum, on the negative impacts of PL'ing in Dunes and elsewhere. It was fairly well recieved in a forum that was hostile to PL'ing and PL'ers in general.

I thought it would be worthwhile to repost in the RDM forums.

---

Hmmm ... I have a confession to make. I PL. Mostly for free.

^^;

I've met a lot of really nice people - many of them are still my mentors and/or close friends.

After having PLed various parties ... I've run into people who've objected to the idea out of hand, and told me so in no uncertain terms. The question I always pose is this:

Is there such a thing as an ethical PL?

I think so, and the Credo is my answer.

Credo of an Ethical PL'er
It is possible. ~_^

1. Steal hate only in emergencies. Tanks are supposed to tank, mages are supposed to cure, nuke, debuff, etc.

2. Haste NIN (they love it at low lvls) ... and as many other melees as you can while safely maintaining your mp pool.

3. Adapt to your party - do not make them adapt to you. If you can't PL without dragging hate onto yourself ... then you shouldn't be PL'ing.

4. Cure I is your best friend. Use Cure II and Cure III sparingly to avoid stealing hate.

5. Ask the WHM for permission to cure party members, and give them the option of determining how much you back them up.

6. PL sparingly, and for the right reasons - not to show off. You're there to cut downtime to nothing.

7. On profit... Friends or LS-mates = free, regardless (personal favor); Strangers = And I quote, "PL me for 100K?" Kindly ask what job, what lvl, where, how long, what lvl their main is, and why they want you to PL ... and you specifically. If you like their answers - and you need the gil (I'm poor -_-) - then feel free.


This is how I think, anyway. ^^ Even people who HATE PLs (and one NIN I know, in particular) ... tend to melt when all I do is Haste and Cure I. Chatting pleasantly in {/tell} doesn't hurt, either.

Take care, everyone.
____________________________
(Lakshmi)
http://saybard.blogspot.com/
Bard tidbits.
#2 Aug 25 2005 at 3:37 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,592 posts
In my opinion, there is no ethical power-levelling of an experience party. Having a lighter touch doesn't suddenly make it acceptable.

When people have no fear of consequences for bad decisions, they get lazy. If the BLM knows you are there to bail him out when he over-nukes, he won't learn hate-control. The healer doesn't learn how to manage MP or the use of enfeebles, the tank turns into a reactionary voker (ugh!), the pullers learn bad XP chaining habits, etc. Your mere presence contributes to creating poor players.

The only time I will ever PL someone it to get them to level 10, or whatever level that particular job can start getting real parties.
____________________________
Red Mage 101 v2.0 -- NIN/RDM|BLM 101 -- Liselle, Phoenix
Greatest RDM thread... ever.
"There is no 'ding', only ZUUL."
#3 Aug 25 2005 at 3:54 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
****
4,324 posts
Don't do it :/
____________________________
Raineer - RDM75 - Siren Server
Clothcraft 100+3
#4 Aug 25 2005 at 4:16 PM Rating: Decent
**
739 posts
Whether its WHM, BRD or RDM, my search comment is always the same:

"Ask for a PL and I'll castrate you."

If I'm asked as DRG/WHM:

"Hahahahahahahahaha..."


On a more serious note, I just don't have much respect for people who ask for PLs or freely give them. For the most part PLs are just a mental illusion - people trick themselves into thinking its faster just because a high level is there helping. but they're really not. But if a PL is actually successcul, the PT loses out on those all-important skillups - ESPECIALLY mages and that's never good.

Edited, Thu Aug 25 17:36:09 2005 by WrathOfFoobar
____________________________
Main - Omgwtfbbqkitten (Mithra) Rank 5 Windurst
50 RNG, 37 WAR, 31 NIN, 20 MNK ~55 Boneworking
Currently Retired: Foobar(Taru) Rank 10 Windurst 75 BRD, 65 RDM, 60 DRG, 40 BLM, 39 WHM, 37 WAR, 31 BST ~50 Cooking
LS: Cognoscenti
Titan Server
The BBQ Kitten Revolution is here.
#5 Aug 25 2005 at 4:47 PM Rating: Default
*
81 posts
I guess the NIN you haste at that low level should always be used to producing that much damage? I guess you dont care if he learns how to do his job! YOU WONT BE THERE FOR HIM FOREVER!
I guess the BLM doesnt need to learn how many nukes are too many nukes per fight? Over nuking isnt a problem to you huh? Should he learn that lesson at a higher level when there is more exp to lose when the whole party dies?

if you are so bored with the game that you contribute to hurting other players on how to do their job effectivly, you are even more of a loser than i thought.

just quit, dont defend yourself, just quit.
#6 Aug 25 2005 at 4:48 PM Rating: Good
***
1,271 posts
There is no such thing as an ethical PL, because PL isnt unethical unless you are imposing it on othes without their consent. The question of PL is not moral in nature really. I say if people wana stand around and beg and whine for PL then let them, they arent unethical for asking, they are lazy. Same goes for people who advertise via /shout to give PL, they aren't unethical either, they are greedy or worse they are enabling laziness, which may be construed as unethical if they are intentionally gimping the knowledge their Power Levelee through their actions.

No, what you are doing is rationalizing an activity you enjoy for whetever reason. Whats more you are coming here and creating a thread whereby you can justify in a public forum your actions. I refuse to validate your suggestion either way. I do not offer PL, I don't ask for PL, its not that it is unethical, it is lazy.

PL is self inflicted stupidity. Don't believe me, well you will one day when you get into that party and the DRK shows up with a underlevelled sub and **** poor gear, and you wonder, "How the **** did he get to level <insert current level here>?" The person asking for/accepting the PL is like that guy in Chemistry class who didn't do his homework all year long and come finals he asks you if he can cheat off you... if you help him because he is a 'nice guy', you are no better than him, in fact it is arguable, you are worse... because you know better.


Edited, Thu Aug 25 18:00:01 2005 by Chieftobique
____________________________
Chieftobique: Windy, Elvaan
99BLM.RDM.WHM.BRD.SMN.BLU.PLD.DRK.
99WAR.THF.MNK.NIN.RNG.DRG.SAM.BST.DNC
13PUP.COR.SCH
Zenith: 5/5(14/02/10)
Fish:100{Fishing Items: ALL(09/18/10)}
CoP:FIN,ZM:FIN,ToAU:FIN,WoTG:8,InTheNameofTheFather,ACP:0,MCD:FIN,ASA:0
R.I.P. BP Thread 58 Pages
R.I.P. Garuda 03/23/2010
Banned:07/04/09;;, Unbanned:07/09/09^^
Hacked:09/05/09;;, Unhacked:09/19/09^^

"The key to immortality is first living a life worth remembering"
-Master Bruce Lee Jun Fan
#7 Aug 25 2005 at 4:53 PM Rating: Excellent
***
2,347 posts
Being PL when you are a WHM makes the job kinda boring. The last WHM party I was in I meleed because I didn't really need to cure. Only two things good about the party - I capped my club skill and gained 2 levels (32-34). Note, I didn't ask for the PL, PL was already at the party when I joined.

If you want to PL most xp/hour, you will steal hate because that will allow the party to fight things they shouldn't. I am not saying that you should do this, only that it is the most effective way to PL.

#8 Aug 25 2005 at 9:01 PM Rating: Good
**
376 posts
Hmm. Interesting points, all the way around. Duly considered.

There are a lot of people I respect here, and as such, I'll answer as honestly as I can - and as fairly as I can - to all concerned.

Kudos to those who avoided direct personal criticism. ~_^ You know who you are.

In summary:

1)(a)PLing enables a lazy person to reach higher levels, and/or

(b)keeps people from learning the skills they need in order to function well at higher levels.

Answer:
(a)It's a case of he-said, she-said. The truth of the matter is this - if you are a lazy player, there is nothing about having ... or not having ... a PL that is going to change this. Granted, some new players simply don't know any better, and the more experienced players in a party will attempt to correct them. I maintain that these players will be corrected -regardless- of whether or not they are in a PL'd pt. That's how I learned - that, and reading the sticky topics posted here. The majority of the 'horror stories' you read on these forums are exceptional, extreme cases - from the vocal minority of the Vana'diel population.

(b)A -bad PL- will keep a party from getting the necessary skillups. A -good PL- will not. It's been my experience that good players do not change their play style when a PL is involved - especially tanks and mages.

Part of 'Ethical PL'ing' is allowing for as much skillup room as possible without getting involved. WHM can easily achieve the proper skill levels in a PL'd experience party ... if the PL knows not to over-cure. BLM will also quickly discover why not to overnuke in a pt after they get knocked into the red a few times. A PL may not be looking at all times - and death is, admittedly, a great teacher.

What I've heard here is that taking hate as the PL is -the best way- to PL. Going out on a limb - it's not. It takes a little more finesse to let go of the reins and cure sparingly, but it can be done. I'm advocating smarter PL's, among those who engage in it.


2)PLing is wrong/evil/greedy.

Answer: Hmm. That's an interesting way to put it. I don't have nearly as much experience as a lot of other RDM's here. I'm still learning. However, I think PL's are good - or have the potential to be good. I am, in fact, defending the practice. This is also why I addressed the moral question. The strongest objectors tend to cite moral rather than practical reasons. Vana'diel is a community environment. This means that, in addition to meeting nice people, we encounter not-so-nice ones as well. When working in a team ... it's quite possible for someone who isn't a team player to ruin the experience for everyone. That's unfortunate, but that's life.

Saying that PL'ing turns a good player into a lazy player is making an attempt at false correlation. In fact, it's something like saying that an abnormally large number of car accidents causes snow ... there are other factors involved. Lurking variables. In the case of the car accident example, the lurking variable is weather conditions.

Why PL? That's a personal decision. You don't want to - you don't have to. I'm not advocating that people go out and PL everyone in sight - I'm advocating that, if they so choose, they should do it wisely.


3)NIN Haste ... you're spoiling them!

Answer: Yes, and they love every minute of it. They -know- they'll rarely get it, because the people who play NIN are usually pretty experienced to begin with.

4)But ... the laziness!

Answer: Don't PL lazy pt's. Fantastic low-lvl pts tend to flourish with the extra push ... and I think it's kinda cool to watch.

5)Most effective way to PL = steal hate.

Answer: Depends on what you mean by 'effective.' If you're talking about exp/hour ... then maybe. Truly effective PLing will enrich a pt, not hamper it.

This was originally posted in order to give some view as to how PLing should be done - not to advocate that every RDM go out and PL. This is for those few that do, for their own reasons. I don't believe that PLing, in and of itself, encourages laziness.

And on that note - thank you to those who presented logical and coherent points of view. I may disagree with your ideas, but not with you. ~_^

Have a pleasant evening, everyone.


P.S. I'm in it only for the money! >=)
____________________________
(Lakshmi)
http://saybard.blogspot.com/
Bard tidbits.
#9 Aug 25 2005 at 9:53 PM Rating: Good
***
2,347 posts
My belief is that if I was going to spend the time to power level someone, I want them to earn the maximum amount of xp/hr so that I can get on to doing something else. This means getting the mob to attack me, since with phalanx up, I get hit for a very low amount of damage.

I don't power level very often, and only for ls members. All of the ls members I have power leveled already have other high level jobs, some with multiple high level jobs. I do admit that the people partied with the ls members could be adversely affected by being power leveled (by not learning their job).

We have a difference of opinion. Mainly because I fall into the "don't like to power level camp." Therefore, if I do end up power leveling ls members as a favor, I want them to level as quick as possible.

I remember a while back a well respected RDM wrote a guide on power leveling and he suggested to have the mob attack the PL.

http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/db/jobs.html?fjob=2&mid=1099422031222141132&num=6

The thing that bugs me about this post is that you advocate something - power leveling, then you advocate a style that makes you bad at doing it.

Edited, Thu Aug 25 23:07:05 2005 by jotaguro

Edited, Thu Aug 25 23:19:03 2005 by jotaguro
#10 Aug 25 2005 at 10:14 PM Rating: Decent
**
845 posts
I don't have any particular reservations about Pleveling people to about 10-15 or so (especially NIN to 12). The solo levels are pretty lame and even if you suck at soloing a job it won't much hurt your ability to play the job once you're in a real party.

Powerleveling parties that are 20+ is just bad for the players, because they don't learn how to play their jobs with a party of their peers, and you get high level numbers without any real experience.

Rushing to 75 so you can be a bad RDM at 75 doesn't help anyone. The people who've worked for it won't respect you, the people you party with will know you're inexperienced, and you just end up looking like a gilbuyer: cool stuff, no clue how to use it.
____________________________
Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

Arachnius, Pandemonium Rank 10 Windurst, Rank 10 Bastok, Rank 9 San d'Oria
BLM 75, RDM 75, WHM 75, SMN 59, BRD 65
(Yep, my profile's out of date. Deal with it.)
#11 Aug 25 2005 at 10:46 PM Rating: Good
Jack of All Trades
******
29,628 posts
Quote:
My belief is that if I was going to spend the time to power level someone, I want them to earn the maximum amount of xp/hr so that I can get on to doing something else. This means getting the mob to attack me, since with phalanx up, I get hit for a very low amount of damage.


You are robbing the party of skillups, which makes you the bad PL, unfortunately.
#12 Aug 25 2005 at 10:47 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
175 posts

Just my two cents: I think we can all agree there are a lot of bad players out there... Regardless of what job they are. It seems it is en vogue in FF these days to rush your way to level 75 as quickly as possible. I still remember my THF friend and I at level 31 in Gusgen Mines trying to get a key drop, then sneaking our way to find the chest for RSE (which was also very creepy too >.>;) But the point is, I think all the time people are running their way through the levels - Contrary to all the patches SE puts out, apparently Real Money Trade is higher than it has ever been. So what we end up with is a whole lot of people level 75 with gear they bought with the gil they bought... I just don't get it.. I bought this game to "play" it.. Endgame is fun, but I worked hard to get where I am. It has taken a full year to get RDM to 75 and I learned some very hard lessons along the way. But in the end I love my job and learning how to work in a party at level 12 set the pace for me all the way up.

In the end, my advice: Don't P-level If its your buddy who is levelling his fifth job at level 4 in Gustaberg, thats not an issue.. But Pleveling is just a symptom of everything I think is wrong with this game that people are now thinking is a "race."

Sobius
____________________________
RDM 75 / BLM 75 / WHM 75 / PLD 75
http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?116227
"I swore I'd never become a job ***** and I did -_-"
#13 Aug 25 2005 at 10:55 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,347 posts
Quote:
You are robbing the party of skillups, which makes you the bad PL, unfortunately.


In my opinion there is only bad PL (good PL doesn't exist). Besides what skillups are you denying besides evasion, shield, parry and healing?


Edited, Fri Aug 26 00:08:05 2005 by jotaguro
#14 Aug 25 2005 at 11:50 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,603 posts
Ezzelin wrote:
Hmmm ... I have a confession to make. I PL. Mostly for free.
Said in your 1st post.

Ezzelin wrote:
P.S. I'm in it only for the money! >=)
Said in your second post.

I'm not making a personal attack on you. But if you want to try rationalize a subject as touchy a power-leveling. Then try not to contradict yourself with statements such as these. People like me will notice everytime.
____________________________
~Vendict of Alexander~

#15 Aug 26 2005 at 1:42 AM Rating: Good
Jack of All Trades
******
29,628 posts
Quote:
In my opinion there is only bad PL (good PL doesn't exist).


Only a Sith deals in absolutes. :3

Quote:
Besides what skillups are you denying besides evasion, shield, parry and healing?


Well, out of those, shield and parry are the ones that can really fall behind to the point where they will hamper performance, and if you ask any competent tank, they will tell you that these skills add a great deal to their survivability.
#16 Aug 26 2005 at 5:58 AM Rating: Good
***
2,347 posts
Quote:
Only a Sith deals in absolutes. :3



Red Mages (with BLM sub) have some sith powers -

1) We can choke the opponent.
2) We can attack them with a light saber (sword).
3) We can cast lightning (thunder).
4) We can raise the dead (in the last star wars movie, palpatine said that only the sith could bring back to life loved ones).

So maybe I am a sith?
#17 Aug 26 2005 at 8:22 AM Rating: Good
*
179 posts
I've read some interesting posts on this thread and seen some points that I would not have thought about. I love when this community debates without flaming, because we have many thoughtful and intelligent people on these boards.

My take on PLing is slightly different. Currently I am PLing my brother who is a THF to 15. Now, my brother is an experienced player who left the game for WoW and EQ and has since come back because he missed it, and hated talking to me about it without being able to play. The point is: if I do PL someone, it is only because they have significant game experience already. The person knows how to work within the party system, and they know how to play their job.

I will also PL LS members for free (especially to help them get subs out of gimpiness). When I PL parties, I am very careful about how I do it. I usually work with the WHM to cover their healing if they get low on MP during a chain. I will haste the tank (PLD or NIN) because I know how useful that can be, and at the mid levels, they will be getting hasted soon enough (I like to give them a taste). If a BLM is an idiot and continually overnukes, I will let the mob eat him/her, or let the party deal with the problem. My PLing is only to facilitate the speed of the party, not to gimp others. I allow the tanks to tank, the mages to work their skills, and I simply make the party as efficient as possible.

I don't enjoy PLing, I only do it as a favor to people that I know, and who I know will appreciate it. I remember stopping to go back and level my subs all the way to 37 when I hit 60s with RDM. I remember how painful it was to deal with people who didn't know their jobs (especially RDMs). I tried to help them with friendly advice in tells, but mostly it was an exercise in frustration. Most of the PLing that I do is solely to help my LS mates get through that period with as little suffering as possible (as well as a sympathetic ear). Remember that a bad party will fail in spite of PLers, I've seen it happen.
____________________________
Aedrios of Diabolos
Hume Male Main: RDM75/BLM37/WHM38
Bastok Rank 10 LS: Escape, PheonixPinion
Max fame everywhere except Norg ><
AF Done (3/19/05)
G1[X] G2[X] G3[X] G4[X] G5[X]
Yes, I am the Refresh monkey!
{secret}{Red Mage}{alliance}{Gather together}

New RDM in need of help? Find a Mentor
#18 Aug 26 2005 at 8:49 AM Rating: Decent
*
70 posts
Honestly, is there a ethical or none ethical way? If someone asks for one and offering you money, take it if you want. Yes or no, it's up to you. Respect? I have not seen an ounce of respect since I've gotten past 45. So, I have no idea why you all are complaining about how good or not good a PL is because it's not up to someone else to make the decisions you make. But the original poster I applaud you on your kindess.
____________________________
Um...yeah...right...
#19 Aug 26 2005 at 9:20 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
140 posts
If you want to cut a parties downtime and skill up healing, the best thing to do is let them get through each battle on their own and heal them when they're not fighting. You can't steal hate this way and it lets the WHM start medding earlier.
____________________________
Reizero - Caitsith
#20 Aug 26 2005 at 9:30 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
****
4,681 posts
Quote:
Besides what skillups are you denying besides evasion, shield, parry and healing?


Wow, just wow. Did you even think this statement through? How incredibly ignorant of a viewpoint this is. Ask any high level PLD if their shield and parry skill are important. Ask any NIN or THF if evasion and parry helps them at all. Ask any WHM why they should raise healing. Maybe because, it is their job. I suppose a RDM by the same token shouldn't worry about enfeebling magic? The fact of the matter is, all of those skills are essential to a parties survival. By depriving the tanks of their skills, later parties are doomed to failure when the defensive attributes of the tanks are lacking. For this glaring lack of insight to how a party works, I am tempted to rate you down.

Back to the topic on hand. My best Dunes parties have been without PLs. I remember a party there, constantly getting chain 5s for a few reasons. First, everyone performed their job. Secondly, we fought level appropriate mobs. Lastly, we worked as a team. The puller knew how to time the pulls by watching the WHMs mp and we had virtually no down-time. From this party, it was made obvious to me any PL present would have been better served to walk over a few more steps and camp the VE for a hairpin. PLs do not make a great party better, they only make crappy parties possible to level.

You are indeed doing nothing but filling in the holes, which wouldn't be there if a party knew what they were doing in the first place. You can deny it all you want, but PLing will never allow players to fully learn their roles in a game. If a puller sees that a WHMs mp is at 60% after a fight, well then that next mob is already coming. What the puller didn't notice is that because of the PL, the WHMs mp isn't 30%. By doing so, the puller is not learning his art of timing to maximize xp well. That's just one of many examples I could give.

Plus, don't even try and tell me just because it's someones third job that they can't learn anything more. I have 1 job at 75, another wearing decent amounts of AF, plenty of 37+ jobs and am curently Rank 10 in San d'Oria. But I can and still do learn lots of stuff in the game that a PL would just prevent. Am I a lazy player? Not at all. But it's human nature to beleive you are doing well if you don't fail. And by shielding players from failure early on, you are setting them up for a catastrophe later on that can cause some serious damage. Take the following example.

Fred is taking High School level chemistry, but due to a "kinder" teaching style he does not get a failing grade when he constantly is late to class, forgets his assignments and continually scores low on his exams. But his teachers pass him, and say he has potential. As such, Fred is bolstered and goes to work at a Chemical Production facility upon graduation. After one week one the job, Fred is fired for negligence and tardiness. He had been linked to an on-site explosion and as such the company can not trust him.

Get the point? Fred lost his job because he was never made to take his lumps early on. Quit PLing, or you will just generate more walking time-bombs like Fred.
____________________________
RNG:75 MNK:75 WHM:75 BRD:75 BST:75 SAM:75 WAR:75 THF:75 BLM:75
DRG:72 SMN:63 DRK:55 NIN:49 PLD:42 RDM:41 DNC:37 SCH:37 BLU:37 COR:20 PUP:22
Woodworking:88 Cooking:60 Alchemy:60 Bone:60 Leather:60 Cloth:60 Smithing:60 Gold:54 Fishing:33
#21 Aug 26 2005 at 9:51 AM Rating: Decent
*
126 posts
From what I've seen Powerleveing does lead to shoddiness and lack of skill. I've also noticed something else...

In my server, we always party in Valkurum Dunes from levels 10-20 or so. However, the parties in the dunes are usually BAD. Seriously, finding a decent party at that level is the exception rather than the rule. My last few jobs I've soloed up to 15 or higher just to get away from the pain and suffering, and gotten better exp/hour than I would in most parties. Because the dunes are so painful, though, more and more people are seeking power-leveling there. This means that fewer and fewer people actaully understand how their job works. It's becoming a vicious cycle:

Suffering leads to Powerleveling. Powerleveing leads to N00bs. N00bs lead to suffering....

Please try to teach the people you are with how to do their job properly, whether or not you are PLing them. As the saying goes:

"Powerlevel a man, and you'll give him experience for a day. Teach him how to play, and he will get experience for the rest of his life".
____________________________
Shiek (Elvaan on Gilgamesh)
Job: Whatever I'm in the mood for
Crafts: Alchemy 85, Gold 24, Wood 23, Smithing 14
#22 Aug 26 2005 at 9:54 AM Rating: Excellent
****
4,592 posts
The skill-up issue is a smokescreen. The only skills that will suffer in a party with a PL are Healing, and various defensive skills (of those, evasion is a non-issue to cap even with a PL, and parry/shield/guard are impossible to cap in XP even without one). Healing is possible to cap outside of XP, either spamming at a MH or casting on undead (which is very fast). In truth, having a PL gives people an opportunity to cap skills that they normally would have difficulty doing, like various weapons, Divine for WHMs, Elemental/Dark for RDMs, etc.

Ezzelin wrote:
1)(a)PLing enables a lazy person to reach higher levels...
Answer:
(a)It's a case of he-said, she-said. The truth of the matter is this - if you are a lazy player, there is nothing about having ... or not having ... a PL that is going to change this. Granted, some new players simply don't know any better, and the more experienced players in a party will attempt to correct them. I maintain that these players will be corrected -regardless- of whether or not they are in a PL'd pt. That's how I learned - that, and reading the sticky topics posted here. The majority of the 'horror stories' you read on these forums are exceptional, extreme cases - from the vocal minority of the Vana'diel population.

The time to learn how to tank, nuke, pull, heal, conserve MP and absorb general party dynamics is in the "noob pits", not at level 40-50+. A PL prevents you from learning these basics. This is not "he-said she-said": the presence of a PL eliminates the consequences of failure, and thus the impetus to learn from your mistakes. Yes, it's true that there are a certain segment of players that will be terrible no matter what you do, but they are in the minority.

Now, this doesn't have anything to do with PLing, but it illustrates my point about knowledge: Dual Wield. It's widely believed that the first Dual Wield trait does nothing but allow you to wield two weapons at once, and that the weapon delay reduction doesn't come until DW II. This is patently false, DWI reduces weapon delay by 10%, and I can give you a test to prove it that will take you 10 minutes, tops. But the erroneous information persists, despite the best efforts of people like myself.

That's kind of a roundabout way for me to explain to you why I don't buy into the "these players will be corrected" theory, because it's been this player's experience that -- for the most part -- they will not. Being power-levelled is worse than just buying your account and being a newbie at level 30, because in addition to needing to absorb the "right way" to play, you have bad habits that need to be un-learned.

Take a look at the Echo Chamber of Idiocy, also known as the "Main FFXI Forum". Scan some of the threads in there about game mechanics, and see first-hand how much people learn when their peers are just as ignorant as they are themselves.
Ezzelin wrote:
(b)keeps people from learning the skills they need in order to function well at higher levels.

(b)A -bad PL- will keep a party from getting the necessary skillups. A -good PL- will not. It's been my experience that good players do not change their play style when a PL is involved - especially tanks and mages.

First a quick note: Skill-ups are completely different from intangible "party skills" like how to tank, how to heal, etc. In-game skills are not an issue with a PL, as I mentioned at the beginning of this post. Anyway.

It's been MY experience that good players DO change their playstyle when they have a PL, ESPECIALLY tanks and mages. How you haven't noticed this, I can't even begin to fathom. Sure, the tanks might still try to keep aggro, but they will never face the consequence of having a party members die because they made a mistake: this turns out reactionary vokers, people who only try to grab aggro when they lose it. Sure, the mages might continue to enfeeble for skillups, but they won't fully appreciate the value of enfeebles for extending chains. The WHM might still heal, but they won't ever have their nose mashed to the grindstone and be forced to make tough decisions about how to spend their MP, they aren't going to learn the finer points of conservation. The puller doesn't even need to pay attention to the status of the party, they can just grab mobs willy-nilly with no downtime whatsoever. This leads to high-level pullers who don't understand why everyone wants them to wait between chains 0-2, and just grab mobs until the party is exausted and think they are doing well. The obvious point about the DDs is that they don't learn that tanking is a group effort, and won't hold back (I'm looking at you, Souleater + Berserk + Last Resort + Guillotine).

This is only scratching the surface. By PLing, you are delaying when players learn these skills, and by delaying, you are allowing them to learn bad habits that are extremely difficult to break when the time comes. I can't ram this point home enough: if you remove the consequences of failure, people will not learn from their mistakes, period, end of story, that's all she wrote.

I understand your concept of a "good" PLer and a "bad" one, but in eyes, you've only described "bad" and "less bad". The only good PLer is one that doesn't PL at all, imo.

EDIT: This post is missing a story, so I'll include one. The point where I decided for certain that I hated power-levelling was when I was levelling up my Ranger.

We were in the Dunes, had a pretty decent party (tank, two mages, rest DDs, the usual), and we were doing pretty well for a Dunes party (chain 2-3). We had some close calls, but everyone was more or less doing their jobs. Then the PL showed up, a friend of one of the members.

The party changed dramatically. The efficiency from before was replaced by artifical PL-efficiency. I had a parser running at the time, and I just said "#$@# it" and started going all out, typically doing 40-50% of the damage in every fight, basically becoming the de-facto tank. We started hitting Chain #6, straight up (I was pulling). There was no incentive whatsoever for me to stop machine-gunning the mobs, there was no other way to hit C6, and that's what everyone wanted so that they could get XP.

The end result was a party that gained 3-4 levels quickly, and next to zero knowledge about their respective classes. Now granted, with me it didn't matter: I know how to play a RNG. But the tank eventually stopped even trying to take aggro from me, the RDM ran up into melee, etc etc. After that party was over, I decided that I was never going to PL another group of players again.

Edited, Fri Aug 26 11:10:47 2005 by MargavineLiselle
____________________________
Red Mage 101 v2.0 -- NIN/RDM|BLM 101 -- Liselle, Phoenix
Greatest RDM thread... ever.
"There is no 'ding', only ZUUL."
#23 Aug 26 2005 at 2:24 PM Rating: Good
***
1,603 posts
Wow Marg,

Almost the same thing happened to me as in your story. Except I was leveling my war in Crawlers Nest. I know, PL's in CN, what the **** has this game come to?

Anyway, this was a party of 6 at first with no PL. Then the tank left, and someone said that their LS member was coming to PL. I pleaded no, and that I would just change subs. But the party did not agree with me, so I kept subbing thf.

PL showed up, and I was determined to not let him take hate from me. I ended up being the tank, puller, and DD for the rest of my time in this party. PL was a 75 rdm. I used ranged attacks to pull, then voked it on the way back. As soon as the PL threw out cure III or IV, I unleashed SA+Sturmwind, and got hate right back. Then I threw up Warcry, then voked again, and the mob was mine. Eventually, everyone just let loose, and stopped doing their jobs. I pulled everything in sight, and didn't even scan first. I was getting /tells from other partys to slow down because my party and I hogged all the mobs.

I ate so many Death Scissors that night, that would have left me for dead had it not been for the PL. Whm just stood and spammed banish, and banish II. Rdm was really the only one to keep playing as if there was no PL, I was amazed at that. But my point being the same. That these methods would not work for bringing mobs down w/o the presense of a PL.

This was the last time that I ever let myself play so selfishly. I look back at it now, and think of myself as a total nOOb for playing like that, and allowing myself to do what I know is not the right way to play this game.

I vowed that I will never PL, or accept a PL again... ever.
____________________________
~Vendict of Alexander~

#24 Aug 26 2005 at 2:54 PM Rating: Good
**
368 posts
I remember in a pt in Boyahda Tree... 52-53 pt. The rng in the pt said he had a "PL".

And I was like, "...is that possible?"

A taru lvl 73 whm shows up and casts a protect and shell cycle everytime it wears. But instead of throwing out a long list of cures(for the pt), she and the rng spammed:

OXOXOXOXOXOXO /lick! (in say)

She was there to cure her rng husband alone. Didn't give a **** when anyone else got sickle slashed.

The kind of PLing that taru whm pulled, that I find really unethical. When you spam your make out sessions in the chat log and I can't concentrate on enfeebles and the refresh cycle cause there's too much, "Oh Oh! /lick!" to see :(

*****
But seriously, I only PL my ls mates on very lower lvl jobs. Or the march to get thf to 15 somewhere in the maze/korollakala(sp?) Or I PL my brother's lower lvl jobs cause I owe him money irl <.<;

*edit for some typos*

Edited, Fri Aug 26 19:23:20 2005 by Redsilent

Edited, Fri Aug 26 19:31:01 2005 by Redsilent
____________________________
Redsilent (Retired) Windurst Rank 8 (CoP 2-5)
LS -Social: HeroicSouls |
Server - Fairy
Jobs: [75 Rdm][75 Whm][57 Thf][53 Smn][66 Drg]
RDM AF[6/6]WHM AF[6/6]DRG AF [6/6]THF AF [4/6}
#25 Aug 26 2005 at 3:03 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,347 posts
Great post Marg, you seem to be able to capture exactly what I am thinking and put it into words.

Rate up.

#26 Aug 27 2005 at 7:51 AM Rating: Excellent
*
225 posts
I think the only people able to point fingers and call names when it comes to PL'ing are those who have never accepted a PL themselves. This means leaving a party in the dunes when a PL shows up, etc. Call those being PL'd or those doing the PL'ing all the names you like, but if you have ever been the recipient of a PL it just makes you a hypocrite.

For the record, I basically only PL my LS-mates who are leveling their 9th subjob or in similar situations, but I can think of a lot worse to get angry and name-call about than someone trying to actually helpsomeone else out (fancy the notion @.@)!
____________________________
¡!¡Civet¡!¡
Phoenix Server
75 @ BRD RDM WHM NIN

« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 1 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (1)