Each year with the extended family we do one of those gift exchange "games". Everyone brings a gift, all of them are put into a pile, people go up in order and grab one or take someone elses, etc. Nothing extraordinary.
Something like a 15 dollar gift limit. People usually bring various snack foods. Cheese, meat, and crackers, various Holiday candies, popcorn, chocolates, nuts. Things people would enjoy but wouldn't end up as clutter or landfill fodder. Sometimes the occasional DVD or some gimmicky tool set. But then there's always someone who brings the ****** gift. This year someone brought a six pack of toilet paper... which was definitely a ****** gift. (Pun not necessarily intended).
A 6 pack of toilet paper... that really comes off as cheap, and pretty offensive to everyone playing the little game who brought things.