it's a myth, he doesn't drop the earring, he can't lol.
i've mastered claiming him now with stun. killed him 10 times without a drop TEN TIMES!
that's 0/10 people
contacting a GM right now to see if maybe something technical is keeping me from getting drop.
this sucks
EDIT: never got response from GM, but i finally got the earring! only took 11 kills!
Edited, Wed Sep 21 21:48:46 2005