those bards all suck. its rather obvious they are merit whores and not much else. skill is very important if you actually want to be useful on god fights aside from being a buffwhore (which is very boring).
landing elegy on kirin, landing requiem on byakko are bragging rights only bards can have. and if you need charisma, we have 2 etudes that can easily add +40 to our total.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but RDM/NIN is only good as a solo class. You'll probably get the invites because of refresh, but no party with half a clue would take a RDM/NIN over a RDM/mage. On a personal level, RDM/NIN replying to me with 'Sorry, this is my only sub' = not in my party.
Wow, this would be a great cape for a brd or smn... Don't really see why a ninja would need it? But since a jester cape+1 would be better for chr stats......
I dont think a Ninja would use this. However from what i gather a rdm who subs nin could benefit a lot from this. The mp +25 is a definate plus for a Rdm.
Idk i could see this cape being relatively useful.
As a bard your singing skill effects your songs sticking. I am not a high level bard, but as a Blm and Rdm, i know that at some point i can have all the int in the world, and without enough magic skill my spells won't stick. I would imagine there would be a very similar "diminishing return" on super high chr, but thats just my thaught. 30 mp is pretty hot for a brd though no matter what.
Summoner: From what a ls mate has said about summoner (he is 56 level or so)your avatars effectiveness is determined by your summoning skill. Assumeing that is the case, then this cape with a bunch of other summoner stuff would make your avatars useful in combat maybe (not talking BP, talking just meleeing with your avatar). The ONLY reason i dont really believe this is there are so many high level smn and things like summoners torques are soooo darn cheap >_<. If smn skill does make your avatars do more dmg in combat, then this could be cool in a big way. If not, its 30 mp <_<.
Not like an everyday useful item, but i could see useing it.
Ninja or /ninja : Your Ninjutsu skill determines how shadows you lose from various attacks, and also determines how well your debuffs stick. This cape is ideal for any soloing job who likes to sub ninja. If a thf/nin can stick blind paralyze and slow they have almost nothing to worry about in the ways of getting hit. As for the MP...this is the highest MP + cape a rdm can wear without spending 20-50 mill on an errant or mahatma cape.
I could see a Brd macro switching this for party buff songs like Minuet because Chr doesnt affect songs like Minuet and Minne but singing skill does, so +5 Singing skill could probably give out more attack for the party.
Otherwise, I think Id rather use the Jesters Cape +1 for debuffing mobs.
EDIT: Wow, was I an idiot when postin this; would definitely rather use Astute Cape for Debuffs and then either a Errant/Umbra/Peiste Cape for buffin/idle depending on the situation