daijooky wrote:
But the artwork is not the greatest. It is too reminiscent of all the manga wannabes of the early nineties.
Well, I'm still not the best, but I try my best, and I practice as often as I can. My proficiency (or lack thereof) aside, this 'wannabe' reminiscence is a stylistic choice I've made. I'm not sure that should reflect on my skill rather than how I feel like drawing.
daijooky wrote:
The elvaan seemed to be permanently sad with his ears drooping thru the entire strip.
Again, a stylistic decision. Have you read the FFXI VG Cats? They're all cats, even the humes. Why do I have to exactly mimic the exact way elvaan's look in the game?
daijooky wrote:
And the 'nomad' moogle was naked, no turban or bag anywhere.
I'll admit I didn't add his bag, but who said anything about it being a nomad moogle? It was just a moogle. It could have looked like
this and still been a moogle.
daijooky wrote:
This may seem harsh to many but that is the danger of asking everyone the 'What do you think?' opinion. Most artists tend not ask that question but rather ask 'Do you like it?' And before you all start clicking on reply to flame me, I am a professional artist and have been an art director in the past as well.
I ask this question constantly. I post my art on Penny Arcade forums, and if you want to get torn apart, that's the place to do it. Most of your grievances weren't with the proficiency of the artist to create an appealing piece, which I always admit I need more practice, but instead to pick apart the aspects of the piece that weren't exactly identical to what is seen in game.
I'll point some more out for you. The armor the elvaan is wearing is not even in the game. He's a bit shorter than regular elvaans. There's no speakers in Vana'diel like the ones in the first panel. There's no NPCs standing on the dock.
Your input is appreciated.