I just burned through 3 stacks of inferno crystals, my cooking is 100, had advanced support and all hq's were Egg Soup. This sh*t is a myth. Now I'm irritated, was trying to make a gag gift for my wedding chaparogne.
*EDIT***
Ok everyone, here's the deal. I figured it out. You can only get Humpty Soup if you use LIZARD eggs! Only hq's I got with bird were egg soups, I switched to liz eggs, and alas, Humpty after Humpty. Yay!
Edited, May 25th 2009 7:40pm by Suffer