1/4. The first 3 CCC's popped around the 2 hour mark. The fourth popped after 3.5 hours and dropped the sword. Perhaps longer spawn increases chance of drop. Also had TH1 on all 4 attempts.
I went 1/5 on Nadrs. Took me an entire weekend bc I would leave after killing him to do something else. I killed him on smn72/thf15 and always had a friend come out and give me TH2. 4/5 times I had TH2 and only once did it drop. Really boring to camp so I just left after each kill or logged for two hours. Always had to kill at least 3 place holders when the 2 hours were up. I noticed that CCC always spawns on or very near the bridge right next to the sea monk.I would summon carby and let him get hate then pull carby off of him and turn my back.. This way carby tanks it. I would do this until my thf friend would arrive. DO NOT disengage! CCC will become unclaimed even if he is still attacking carby. I know being unclaimed isn't a prob with this guy but you never know.... Some ****** might run by and see a cool name to kill :P Drop rate is 10% after awhile it will get aggravating lol but when you get it you will be. Be very glad you have it. Good luck
I got today after about 5 tries more or less, with Treasure Hunter 1 & 2 + Thief Knife. I was basically very lucky that no one camps this, because the drop rate isn't too good. It seems like a nice piece to have for that level but nothing extraordinary. It's something nice for people to see when they examine you. Ofcourse, it's a very decent piece to use up until about level 30 When you get that sword with acc +3 and att+4 which I think is called Centurion's sword.
Anyways, I tested it out on regular mobs in Korroloka like spiders. The proc rate of the additional effect of poison is not too great. I still haven't checked if it's a powerful poison versus lower level mobs like Qufim ones (it's level 24, so it'll be used in that area or in level capped areas). Afterwards, I tested it on Aquans like fish to see if it had some sort of hidden effect, and the additional effect did not proct more, nor did I notice anything hidden. Lastly, I tested this on crabs in the area since this is dropped from a crab. I didn't notice more proc rate on crabs, nor did I notice any other hidden effect versus crabs.
im now the proud owner of this sword. i went 1/2 so after reading this i guess i got pretty lucky. first time i showed up and tried to solo him as a 36 bst/whm, got him down to just under 60% before he pwned me. came back later with a 75 thf friend and got the drop. ^^
Just a thought has anyone tried with 4-Leaf Mandragora Bud ?? i'm going to go try it in another 3 hours ^^ i guess i can report back if it works or not ^^ cheers M8's
Just to let you know, Nellihym, THF does not improve drop rates on Rare/ex items. Im 1/1 on this btw. Didn't know it was so rare. Its an awesome weapon for BLUs and the additional effect of poison hits pretty often.
Oh sorry. I've takenmany breaks from FFXI and i usually just learn the updates as i go...Must have been soon they confirmed this because before I took my 3rd break from FFXI in October 2007, some guy would always get on people in my LS about how TH doesn't work and stuff...
Always seems to be people with good drop rates for things and people with bad drop rates. iv known people who go 1/1 or 1/2 on nearly everything while iv had no rare/ex like bounding or hairpin and iv done abou 30kills on each knew 1 person who went 2/2 on hairpin to give to his friend.
me thinks that SE gives 4 out of 5 at the start of the game the cr*p drop spell that never will come off.
Hi all!!! Well currently 0/9 on the Nadrs. There are a few things I noticed that may help people. Although his pop time could be 1-3 hours, I am fairly convinced on the average is about 2hrs. You only have to kill the one clipper to the east or west of the bridge...the one sitting in the little pools. Respawn time of the clippers are about 10 to 13 mins. Rarely have I seen a 10 min respawn though. Typically I put my spells up in place at the 10 min. mark and it usually pops just before or just as my refresh wears...so typically 13 min.
I might be able to help with some of the truths and un-truths about Cargo Crab Cheapass. He did use his poison ability on me the very first one I fought...obviously no drop. He has never attempted it since then...I can say that if it happens its not 100% it will drop...but does it increase the odds...maybe...thats something I am still testing.
I have killed the Sea Monk 5 outta the 9 times...still spawned after 2hrs. Didn't seem to matter for him spawning or not. One thing I observed was that the Sea Monk did respawn shortly after CCC's pop. So I am testing now whether you kill the Sea Monk closer to the time of the pop that it will make a difference.
Doesn't seem to matter what pool the Greater Pugil is in. Cargo Crap Cheapass spawns in the area near the bridge every time I have killed it, never seen a pool spawn yet. Sometimes right on the bridge or next to each corresponding chasm on either side of the bridge and can be on the east or west side. So really in total you need to keep track of 5 spawn points...which is very easy.
He drops 1200 gil, 2 crab meat, & crab shell everytime I have killed him. Finally yes!!! he is miser(which is why my LS and myself have adopted his new name...lol)with his drops if you go 1/1 consider yourself very very lucky. I seriously am hoping the guy that wrote he went 1/40 was exaggerating...lol. Although I have only killed him nine times, I have seen 30+ spawns whether it be other campers or friends. From the other players that I have confirmed results it has dropped about 2 in 26 kills. Some players wouldn't acknowledge my inquiries so it may have dropped more. I have a feeling the drop rate is less than 10% though. Hope this information helps anyone looking for this awsome sword. I will update when I acquire accurate data.
***Edit*** Finally went 1/21 on the sword. I am convinced the Sea Monk does not have anything to do with Cargo spawning or not spawning. Cargo still spawn every time on time when he should have when the monk was dead or alive. Also the poison ability doesn't seem to make a difference in drop rate at all. In reality I believe there isn't anything "special" about Cargo...he seems to act just like every other pop NM in the game. He is just very boring to camp and I believe people notice things that aren't really anything to just occupy their mind. One thing true about him though is that his drop rate is filthy awful. From the data I got, I calculate the drop rate out to being roughly a little less than 5%.
1/2 on DRG/THF. I was down farming slimes one day a few months ago and CCC was up unclaimed. All on his lonesome. I'd camped him with a MNK friend of mine before, but we didn't get the drop for him (he was lvling BLU).
So I killed the little bugger and out pops a Nadrs. Suffice to say I'm pleasantly surprised. I was thinking of lvling BLU for DRG sub anyway, so I can't complain. It's a pretty sword. I've bazaared with it on using my WAR sub just because I could (what can I say? I'm easily contented.)
Ok so i'm back... Last update i was 0/7, now i'm 0/10.
Only thing i have discovered is that killing the Sea Monk will stop CCC from spawning. Took me 4 friggin hours to figure this out. For those who can't put that together, if u kill Sea Monk he wont pop, or it will take an extremely long time to get pop.
And no drop, my friend THF70 or 69 or sumthin didn't get drop in 3 attempts... this is one greedy {******* Sword}.
Currently I am 0/20 on Mr. Crab. We have become good friends over the past few weeks. Sometimes I have nothing else to do, that is when I say to my self "Hey self, I should go check in on my favorite crab, who knows today could be the day he is actually carrying cargo." Alas, it is never the day. I am beginning to hold the Nadrs in such high regard that it could possibly be a mythical weapon. I have almost forgotten the reason why I wanted this sword. Sure it looks cool and everything, but is it really worth it? Everyone should at least meet Colin once, but if he isn't generous and doesn't give you that 1/1 rate I would recommend finding another NM to be friends with. If you really want though, pop in after two hours from when you last saw him, check and see how he is doing and if he has anything for you. It may be a long and vicious cycle, but I know one day Mr. Crab will learn that I only think good thoughts of him, and he will be selfless enough to part with this treasure of his. Until that day, we will see each other quite often Colin. ^_^
hmm i'm slightly confused now, i am on the right amp and have been consistently killing the clippers...3 hours no and no CCC, also no jammer leeches in sight :/